Chapter 1
“ARE GHOSTS real?”
My attention snapped back to my professor as she paced the front of the room. My mind had wandered to the big break in the case I was working, but her words cut through. What had I missed? Why were we talking about ghosts?
World Religions was a recommended elective, and I had to admit, I wasn’t taking it that seriously. In fact, the only reason I was there that morning was because Professor Lawson had told me that if I missed any more classes, I’d drop a letter grade, and my grade was already perilously low. I was a criminal justice major with a human services specialty, at the urging of my boss, and in my senior year. I wasn’t interested in debating the existence of ghosts or talking about folklore and mythology.
“No, ghosts aren’t real,” said a guy in the front row of the class. “There’s no empirical evidence that they exist.”
“There’s plenty of firsthand accounts,” another girl spoke up.
“Sure, and there’s plenty of people who claim they were abducted and probed by aliens too,” the guy responded.
“We’re not talking about your personal fantasies,” the girl shot back.
“Has anyone here ever had an experience with a ghost?” Professor Lawson interrupted. I could have sworn she looked right at me.
I stayed quiet. It just so happened that I did see ghosts—I had as long as I could remember—but I’d be damned if I was going to admit that in class. I’d learned early on that it was better not to talk about it, especially with strangers. I was the weird kid who talked to himself for the first few years of school, and I still got teased about it even in high school whenever someone remembered. Eventually, I learned to ignore most of the spirits.
I’d tuned out again, lost in my own thoughts, when Professor Lawson’s voice broke through once more.
“Cavanaugh?”
I jumped. Hardly anyone ever called me by my full name. I went by Cav almost exclusively.
“What about you?” she said, her eyes boring into mine. “Do you think ghosts are real?”
“What’s real?” I countered. “If someone believes they have experienced a ghost, then it’s more real to them than a—” I paused while I fished for an example. “—Komodo dragon.”
Professor Lawson gave me an amused look. “A Komodo dragon?”
“Yeah, because they believe they’ve seen a ghost in person, but I bet they’ve never seen a Komodo dragon in person.”
“But Komodo dragons are real,” front row guy practically shouted. “Even if you’ve never seen one in person, they’ve been observed, they are at zoos, you can see them on TV.”
“And we all know everything you see on TV is real,” someone else said, and the class laughed.
The debate—argument, really—continued as I zoned out again.
This was my last class of the day, and I was eager to escape and get on the road. I had to drive to Philadelphia, and I wanted to get there while it was still light out.
A week ago, I’d been hired to find a fifteen-year-old kid. A distraught mother had shown up at our office door looking for help. My boss, private investigator Sutton Walker, assigned the case to me. He’d been giving me more of the missing people cases, especially if they involved teens. He said that at twenty-one, I had a better grasp on how teenagers thought than he did. I was new to investigating without his direct supervision, so it was still exciting to get a case of my own.
This particular case was challenging. Summer, the missing kid, was nonbinary, used they/them pronouns, and was having a rough time. While the mother was clearly struggling to understand and tripping over the correct terminology, the father was having an even harder time accepting it all and had been verbal with his disapproval. When school started and some of their classmates at their rural high school started giving them a hard time, the kid took off.
There wasn’t much to go on. Summer was something of a loner at school, and their blog was mostly shared memes and vague text posts about not being understood—no clues as to where they might have gone or if they’d even had a destination in mind.
After asking around and showing photos everywhere I could think of, I’d finally gotten lucky and found my first clue. “Yeah, I remember that baby,” the woman in the ticket counter at the bus station told me the day before. “Bought a ticket to Philly.”
“You’re sure it’s them?”
“Yeah. I mean, I can’t be one hundred, but I’m pretty sure. I only remember because she was alone.”
“They.”
“It was just her.”
“I know, but they use they/them pronouns.”
“Oh honey, I don’t know nothing about all that. I just thought she—”
“They.”
She scrunched up her face. “I just thought they looked so lost and little and scared, and she… they were clearly all alone, and I said, ‘Baby, where you going all by yourself?’ And they just slid the cash to me and said, ‘Away.’ Stood out to me, you know?”
It was something.
When Summer finally posted a selfie with an overpass in the background, Walker sent it to a PI he knew who worked in the Philadelphia area. The PI recognized the location, which meant I was going to the city. I had no idea if Summer was still there, but it was my best shot at finding them.
Finally, after what seemed like forever, the class ended. I grabbed my bag and started for the door, but Professor Lawson called my name.
I stifled a sigh and turned in her direction. She beckoned me closer, so I made my way to the front of the class against the flow of students pouring out of the room.
While it probably didn’t sound like it, I actually liked Professor Lawson. She seemed cool. One of the first things she told us as she introduced herself on day one was that she was a practicing witch. She was a willowy white woman in her midforties with black hair cut in a sharp bob.
“Cavanaugh,” she started as I approached.
“You can call me Cav, Professor Lawson,” I said, cutting her off. “Sorry. It’s just that only my grandmother calls me by my full name.”
She peered at me over her black-framed glasses, her silvery-blue eyes measuring me up. “It’s a good name.”
I shrugged. “You wanted to see me?” I wasn’t trying to be rude, but I was itching to get on the road. It was already midafternoon, and it was a two-hour drive from Baltimore to Philadelphia with no delays.
“Yes. While I appreciate your corporeal form being present in class, I’d love if your mind joined you now and then. I have a sense about you. I feel like you have a lot to offer.”
“Sorry, Professor Lawson. I’m working on a case right now, and I’ve just been distracted lately.”
“Yes, you’ve mentioned a few times that you work for a private investigator. I appreciate how working a job while going to school can be difficult, but when you’re in my class, I’d like to ask you to at least try to be a little more attentive. I can’t help but feel you don’t take me or this course very seriously.”
“Oh! I never meant to make you feel that way.”
She cocked her head to one side. “I notice you didn’t jump to say that you do take this class seriously.”
My cheeks warmed. “I, um… I think it’s an interesting class, and you seem especially interesting, but I guess I don’t really see how this class contributes to my major.”
“So you think that only classes that contribute to your ultimate goal have value?”
“I, uh—”
“What is your major, Cavanaugh?”
I noted the use of my full name, but it wasn’t the time to press the point. “Criminal justice with a human services specialty.”
“And you don’t see how understanding what other people believe might be useful?”
“I mean, when you put it like that….”
“You seem like a very focused young man. You already have your career path chosen, and you’re working to achieve those goals. That’s very admirable. But I think it would be good for you to expand your horizons a little.”
I nodded. “Yes, Professor Lawson.”
She sighed. “Have you heard a word I’ve said?”
“Yes. I promise I’ll pay more attention in class.”
“That’s great, and I hope you do, but if you want to bring your grade up, you’ll need to do more than just pay attention.”
“Like what?”
“Participate in discussions more, for one thing.”
“I can do that.” I would have agreed to about anything at that point just to end the conversation so I could leave.
“Are you interested in some extra credit?”
“Uh…. Sure, why not?”
She looked like she was holding back a smile, but she simply nodded. “Great. I liked what you said today about ghosts being real to people who have seen them. If you write a paper expanding on that idea, I’ll give you some bonus grade points. The better it’s written, the more points you get. Throw in some interviews with people who have seen ghosts and cite your sources and you might even salvage this class.”
The last thing I wanted was another paper to write, but it was a fair bargain. “When is it due?”
“Midterms are coming up and I don’t want to overburden you, so let’s say before winter break. Does that seem doable?”
“Yes, ma’am. Very doable. Thank you. But if you’ll excuse me, I have to drive to Philadelphia now, and I really need to get on the road.”
She studied me silently for a moment, then waved me off. “Drive safe. I’ll see you next week… Cav.”
I broke into a smile. “See you next week!” As I spun around to leave, I was surprised to see one of the other students waiting by the door. I had a momentary flash of embarrassment, wondering how much of our conversation he’d overheard, but then I brushed it off. What did it matter?
I’d noticed him in class—he was gorgeous, so hard to miss—but we’d never spoken, and I didn’t know his name. He was tall, close to six feet, with a narrow waist, broad shoulders, and muscles in all the right places. He wore his hair in shoulder-length dreads, and his honey-brown eyes held a warm intelligence. He didn’t speak much more than I did in class.
“Were you waiting to see me, Kyreh?” Professor Lawson asked.
“Yes, if you have a minute,” he said. He flashed me a smile and a nod as I passed him, and I returned the gesture on my way out the door.
I PARKED my car and took a deep breath. If I’d hoped to arrive with plenty of daylight left, I had failed miserably. An accident on I-95 had caused a traffic backup, and driving in an unfamiliar city had eaten up more time than I’d anticipated. So there I was, parked in a neglected lot just off a busy highway as the sun sank below the horizon and the streetlights flickered to life. Not an ideal situation when looking for a missing person in a potentially dangerous location you’ve never been to before.
I leaned over, popped open my glove box, and rummaged through it until I found the canister of pepper spray I kept in the car for dicey situations. If looking for a teenage runaway in a homeless encampment in Philadelphia after dark didn’t qualify as dicey, I don’t know what would. My boss had a strict no-gun policy that I was more than happy to abide by, but I was on the small side, and my mama didn’t raise a dummy.
I flipped the safety switch back and forth a couple of times, slid the pepper spray into my pocket, climbed out of the car, and headed toward the tent city set up under the overpass. In the twilight, with the added sickly orange light cast by the sodium lamps, it looked especially unwelcoming.
As I neared the campsite, I noticed that in addition to the tents, there were quite a few people lying on the ground, some wrapped up in blankets but some directly on the pavement or on pieces of cardboard. There were at least a dozen people that I could see, and possibly more in the darker areas away from the lights.
I was being watched. A woman in a faded floral dress worn over a pair of jeans stared at me warily as I approached. She was standing protectively in front of a blue tent, feet apart, arms crossed over her chest.
I smiled at her and hoped it translated as friendly and not nervous. I’d been going to school in Baltimore for the past four years, but sometimes I still felt like a country bumpkin.
“Hi,” I greeted her.
She didn’t smile back. Or respond in any way, for that matter.
“I’m looking for someone,” I said as if she had replied. “Maybe you can help me?”
Her eyes narrowed. Up close, I could see the dirt on her face. She was very tan under the grime, and her face was creased. Her hair was dark, though. It was impossible to guess her age, but she looked as if she’d lived a rough life.
I pulled my phone out of my pocket and opened a photo of Summer. I held it up for her to see. I belatedly realized flashing my phone around here probably wasn’t my smartest move.
The woman still didn’t speak, but our one-sided conversation had caught the attention of a nearby tent owner. The gray-haired Black man sitting in the tent crawled out and shambled over. He glanced at the picture on my phone, then at me.
“You might want to put that away.”
I smiled uneasily and slid the phone back into my pocket. At least he’d spoken to me. I shifted my attention to him. “Thanks. Have you seen the person I’m looking for?”
“Ain’t nobody here wants to be found.”
I reached back into my pocket and pulled out a twenty-dollar bill. “I know. And probably for good reason, but I really need to find them.”
He glanced at the bill in my hand. “They a friend of yours?”
“Yeah.” It was a fib. I was a good liar. I lied a lot in my line of work. I had to. “I just want to help.”
He shrugged. “That’s what they all say.”
“Please. It’s important that I find them.”
He held out his hand. I debated with myself for a second, then gave him the twenty. He quickly shoved it into his pocket. “I guess you don’t look like too much of a threat.”
Once again, my boyish stature worked to my advantage. No one was ever intimidated by me. Most of the time that was a good thing, though not always. I felt particularly vulnerable under that overpass, for instance.
He jerked his head toward the darkest part of the lot, deep in the shadows of the overpass. I could make out a few people huddled against the concrete wall. “Over there.” Then he turned and crawled back into his tent.
I turned back to the woman. She hadn’t moved a muscle. She was still glaring at me. I smiled again. “Have a good night.”
I quickly made my way across the camp, weaving through the tents and sleeping areas, trying to be as sensitive to their space as possible. A few people watched me—some with wary expressions, some curious, some impassive—but most ignored me or were in their own little worlds.
As I approached the three figures against the wall, I immediately ruled out one of them. She was far too old and the wrong race. She was also unconscious, legs sprawled akimbo, head rolled back. At least I hoped she was only unconscious.
The other two would take a closer inspection. One lay on their side, face turned away from me, wrapped tightly in a grubby blanket. The other sat with their back against the concrete, knees pulled up to their chest, head down in their arms. They wore a knit cap over their hair, but now that I was just a few feet away, I thought I could see a few pale wisps curling around the edges. Something about the body type and hair made me think I’d found Summer.
I walked over and crouched down by the sitting figure. “Summer?”
The head snapped up and a pair of huge round eyes met mine, theirs filled with fear.
“Hey, it’s okay. My name is Cav. I’m here to help.”
Summer looked around frantically, as if searching for an escape route.
“Your mom really wants you to come home.”
Their eyes found mine again. “Yeah, right.”
“No, really. She hired me to find you. She’s really worried.”
“And Dad?”
“Honestly, I don’t know. I haven’t met him. He’s writing my check, though, so that has to count for something, right? And trust me, I’m not cheap.” I laughed, but Summer didn’t crack a smile.
“Who are you?” they asked.
“Cav Crawford. I’m a private investigator.”
“How did you find me?”
“A bit of luck and a lot of work.”
“I’m not going home. Not with my dad.”
“Has he hurt you?”
Summer rolled their eyes. “Not physically, if that’s what you mean. But he’s sure made it clear how little he cares about my feelings or who I am.”
“I’m really sorry to hear that. Your mom seems to be trying, though. She really wants to know you’re okay.”
“What… what did she say?” Summer was looking anywhere but at me.
“She told me she was worried sick. She hasn’t been sleeping—”
“I mean about me. What did she say about me?”
“Oh. She said that you told them that you’re nonbinary a couple months ago, and that you asked them to call you Summer and use they/them pronouns. She said your dad was kind of a jerk about it.”
“She said that?”
“Maybe not in those exact words, but yeah. She also said school was really rough for you this year.”
“Understatement.”
“She wants to help with that, though. She said you wouldn’t have to go back to school until you were ready. She’s already talked to the school. Apparently they’re doing some sensitivity training about what being nonbinary means and stressing their zero-tolerance bullying policy. You’ll be protected if… when you go back.”
Summer looked surprised. “Are you serious? They’re actually doing all that?”
“That’s what your mom said.”
“Huh.”
“So what do you think? You ready to leave this luxury resort and head back with me?”
Summer glanced around. “They’ve been nice to me here. Mostly. Some of them watch out for me.”
“Your mom would like to watch out for you too.”
They avoided eye contact.
“Look, if you don’t feel safe at home—”
“It’s not that.”
“Okay, then I think you’ve made your point, don’t you? Let’s go home.”
I stood up and held out a hand. After a moment’s hesitation, they slid their small hand into mine, and I pulled them to their feet.
IT WAS almost midnight when I got back to the office. I’d dropped Summer off at home to a very relieved mother and a surprisingly emotional father. I had a feeling he’d be making more of an effort going forward. I could have gone home, but I wanted to get my notes typed up while they were fresh on my mind. That way our office manager, Jordan Fisher, would be able to submit the final report and billing to our satisfied clients as quickly as possible. Besides, I was keyed up and excited from such a happy ending. Most of our cases involved cheating spouses or insurance fraud, so this was a cause for celebration.
Our office was located in a slightly run-down 1980s-era strip mall on the outskirts of Baltimore City. Our neighbors included a Mexican restaurant, a cell phone store, a thrift shop, a sad little pet store, and a space that seemed to change at least once a year but was currently serving as a Korean church.
The restaurant was going strong, the sound of lively Tejano music spilling out into the parking lot, but the rest of the storefronts were locked up and dark. I let myself into our office and flipped on the light before locking the door behind me, then went directly to the security panel to disable the alarm.
If the alarm was armed, I knew I was alone in the building. It wasn’t uncommon for Walker to work late nights, something I often gave him a hard time about. It wasn’t lost on me that I was apparently falling into the same bad habits.
I crossed the reception area and paused by Jordan’s desk, checking to make sure there was nothing in my inbox. His desk stretched across the far end of the room, with a door to one side that led to a long hallway. Three doors opened off the hallway—the bathroom, my office, and Walker’s office.
When I’d started at the agency as an intern in my sophomore year, I’d mostly worked the front desk. I quickly showed an aptitude for investigation, though, and Walker found my knowledge of technology and social media especially helpful, so when my internship ended, he’d offered to keep me on—on the condition that I got my private investigator’s license. I did, and my reward was my own office. I loved it, even if it was basically a glorified broom closet.
I unlocked my office and turned on the tarnished brass architect’s lamp that had belonged to my father. I sat down at the desk, opened my case notes, filled in the night’s happenings, then shot the finished product off to Jordan in an email. I was just locking up when my phone vibrated. It was a text from my friend and roommate, Haniah.
Are you coming home tonight? She worried about me when she knew I was out working a case.
Leaving the office. On my way home now, I texted.
Are you seriously at work right now?
I laughed and shot back a quick reply. Yes, I wanted to type up my notes. Another successful conclusion to a case.
You’re ridiculous. Are you hungry?
I realized that I was, in fact, starving. I hadn’t eaten since lunch. So hungry.
Come home. I’ll order pizza.
Be right there.
I locked up and headed home. Haniah and I rented a two-bedroom apartment on the second floor of an old Victorian in Lauraville, a neighborhood in the northeast corner of Baltimore. It was convenient, being equidistant from my office and Waring University, but also cheap for how nice it was.
As I opened our door, Haniah was waiting for me with a disapproving scowl, arms crossed under her generous bosom in an oversize orange tee that she would never be caught dead in outside of our apartment. Even dressed down, she was stunning—taller than me and curvaceous, with dark skin, upturned catlike eyes, and a cloud of dark natural hair.
“Uh, hi,” I greeted her.
“Only you would be working at midnight on a Wednesday night,” she said in a mock-scolding tone. “And forget to eat.” Haniah had grown up in Ghana, and while she spoke fluent English—along with at least three other languages—her accent added a lyrical cadence to everything she said.
“You don’t know that I forgot to eat,” I said as I hung my keys on the rack.
She raised an eyebrow as I closed and locked the door.
“Okay, I forgot to eat.”
“The pizza should be here soon,” she said with a chuckle as she headed into the living room.
I followed her and dropped onto the sofa as she curled into one of the big, comfy chairs by the window.
“How was your day?” I asked.
“It was fine. Just class and homework. You closed your case?”
“Yeah, a happy ending for a change.”
Before I could elaborate, her phone buzzed.
“Pizza’s here!” She jumped up to answer the door. Moments later, she returned carrying a large pizza box. She popped it open and offered it to me first, so I grabbed a piece and started eating. Haniah took a slice for herself and then set the box on the coffee table before she reclaimed her place in her favorite chair.
“So you said your case had a happy ending?”
“Yep. Best-case scenario,” I said with my mouth full.
“So which case was this?”
“The runaway teen,” I explained.
“Ah. You didn’t tell me much about that one. Why did they run away?”
“They were misunderstood at home.”
“What teen isn’t?” Haniah came to America for college partly because she was bisexual and could be more open here.
“Well, they’re nonbinary, so it’s a whole other can of worms.”
Haniah made a face. “Ew. Why would you have a can of worms?”
“It’s just a saying,” I explained. “It means that something is a lot more complicated or unpleasant than you might think.”
“But why worms?” Haniah insisted.
“It doesn’t matter!” I said, exasperated. “The important part is that I found them.”
“Where were they?”
“In a homeless camp in Philly. That’s why I was working so late. But they’re home safe and sound now.”
“Good,” Haniah cooed, the worms forgotten. “Poor baby. I’m so glad you found them.”
“Me too. The place where I found them…. It was awful. I know we have plenty of homeless camps here in Baltimore, but it was so intimidating. I can’t imagine being out there on my own at Summer’s age. They’re so tiny. It could have been really bad for them.”
“But you found them and they’re back home,” she said. “Happily ever after.”
I sighed. “There’s no such thing. Life isn’t a Disney movie. Their dad sounds like a dick.”
She frowned. “Is he abusive?”
“I don’t know. Maybe emotionally. But he seemed really relieved that Summer was home, so who knows. Maybe he’ll come around.”
She nodded. “Either way, the case is over. You have to let go.”
“Intellectually, I know you’re right. Family stuff just gets to me, you know.”
Her face softened. “You’ve got a great family.”
“Oh, I know. But family means a lot to me.”
“Of course. You experienced a lot of loss,” she said.
“That’s an understatement,” I muttered.
When I was a baby, most of my family died in a tragic multi-car accident caused by a drunk driver. My father, his parents, and my maternal grandfather all died. Only my mom, her mother, and I survived, although my grandmother was paralyzed from the waist down.
If that wasn’t enough, when I was fifteen, my mom was diagnosed with an aggressive form of breast cancer. She was dead within a year.
“But you still have your nana,” Haniah said. “And Jason and Eli. And best of all, you have me!”
I rolled my eyes and laughed. “Lucky me.”
Jason and Eli were my adopted dads. Jason was my mom’s best friend since grade school, so I’d known him my whole life. He and Eli were a huge support when Mom got sick. There was never any question about where I’d go when she passed.
I shook off those memories. “But enough of that. Let’s change the subject.”
“Of course.” She stood up. “I’ll get us some drinks. Any preference?”
I shook my head as I shoveled in more pizza. She handed me an ice-cold can of Natty Boh beer on her return.
We chewed and drank for a moment before Haniah asked with exaggerated casualness, “So… how’s your love life?”
“That wasn’t what I had in mind when I said to change the subject.” My love life was a bit of a sore subject since the death of my last boyfriend.
“You can’t stay alone forever,” she said.
I opened my mouth, showing off my chewed pizza, then swallowed. “I can if I want to.”
“Is that what you really want? That’s not healthy. You’ve got to get back out there eventually, Cav,” she scolded.
“Oh my God, I will. When I’m ready.”
“It’s been a year.”
“So?”
“So that’s a long time to be alone and sad. You’re still seeing your therapist, right?”
“Duh.” I reached for another slice of pizza.
“What does she say?”
“She says you should stay out of my business.”
“All you do is work, go to school, and hang out with me. You should be dating and having fun.”
“We have fun.”
“That’s not what I mean, and you know it.”
I threw my hands up. “When am I supposed to even have time to meet guys? I’ve got work and school.”
Haniah huffed. “That’s just an excuse. You had time for Mason.”
I tried not to flinch at his name. “And how would I meet these hypothetical guys?”
“It’s the twenty-first century,” she said with exaggerated patience. “There are dating apps.”
“Yeah, I’ve been on them,” I snapped. It was how I’d met Mason. I’d deleted all of the apps when we started dating and hadn’t re-downloaded them since he disappeared. It felt unfaithful, somehow, as if I’d be defiling his memory. “I’m not looking for a hookup.”
“Who said anything about a hookup?” she said. “But while we are on the subject, maybe that is exactly what you need.”
“What I need is more time.”
“How much more time? Don’t you think Mason would want you to move on?”
I stopped chewing and stared.
“What?” she asked.
“You don’t know what he would want,” I said quietly.
Want to keep reading?
Buy this book Excerpt © Josh Aterovis. Published by Dreamspinner Press.