Chapter One
The Last of the Unplucked Jems
“There’s always stripping,” Tori offered from her back on Jem’s ugly carpet.
Sprawled on his sofa—legs over the back, head hanging down to the floor—Jem turned to look at her. “I’m flattered,” he said flatly. “Except for how everything about that sounds terrible.”
The hours, first of all. Jem taught kindergarten; he needed to be in bed at a decent time to keep up with the little gremlins. Then there was the waxing… unless chest hair was in vogue again, which, maybe? Fashion was one thing, but who could keep up with body-hair trends? Who would want to? And Jem could dance well enough, but the idea of anonymous strangers pawing at him had lost its appeal in his junior year of college.
“Well, you’ve got to do something.”
Unfortunately, Tori had a point. Jem’s beloved-but-ancient Prius needed, like, a heart transplant. It was hanging in there for now, held together with duct tape and a prayer, but it wouldn’t last indefinitely, and Jem had depleted his emergency savings four months ago when he broke his foot walking down his apartment stairs in his Crocs and had to take three weeks off work.
“Maybe I could sell a kidney,” he mused.
Tori thwacked him with a pillow. “Be serious.”
“I am.”
“You only have one kidney left , Jem. You need it.”
Sighing, Jem let himself roll off the couch entirely. He mostly didn’t land on Tori. “Well, what else am I going to do? Call up my father and extort him for the money to go back to school and become an investment banker?” Jem’s father had traded the right to speak to his illegitimate child for the aforementioned kidney, which his real son needed. Considering Jem hadn’t even known who his father was until he was seventeen, he didn’t think the relationship was much of a loss.
Tori barked with laughter. “God, that’s the most depressing thing I’ve ever heard you say. Imagine you in a suit and tie every day, debating, like, stock futures or whatever.”
“Is that what investment bankers do?”
“I don’t know, Jem, I’m a music teacher.”
Maybe Jem should’ve been a music teacher. The subject specialty meant Tori got paid more. “I’m not going back to waiting tables during the schoolyear.” He could handle it during the summer, but, well. Sleep. Jem liked it. And it was only January. “Ugh. I guess I could coach volleyball next year.” That paid extra, and Jem was athletic enough to pass as a coach for preteens.
“Yeah, but you need money this year.”
“Thanks, I’m aware.”
She turned to look at him, her hair fanning out across the floor.
“How do you manage it?” he asked.
“I married well.”
Tori’s wife, Ivy, was a lawyer specializing in some kind of software IP. “Right,” Jem said. He paused. “Hey, is Ivy’s brother still bi?”
Tori thwacked him with her arm instead of a pillow this time. “Yes, and he’s still an asshole you hate.”
Oh yeah. That was a deal-breaker. Jem didn’t actually hate Mike. His podcast was funny. The documentary film he and his work partners had done about the creation of their podcast was hilarious. But spending more than five minutes in a room with Mike made Jem want to swan-dive off the nearest balcony. His kids would miss him.
Tori tapped her fingers against the floor. “You know, while the specifics are all wrong, the concept’s not bad.”
Something in her tone made Jem sit up. “What do you mean?”
Tori sat up too. “I mean, not marrying for money, but like, a sugar-baby situation.”
Jem balked. “You want me to be an escort ?”
“No! I mean we should find you a rich sugar parent to line your bank account.”
For a moment Jem let himself process what she’d said. “No, sorry, I am going to need you to explain the difference.”
Tori held out one hand, palm up. “Escort,” she said. “Which, okay, that’s—you know, there are escorts who don’t have sex. You get paid to go on dates that may or may not involve sex.” She raised the other hand. “Sugar baby. You enter into a financial arrangement with a particular person and, I don’t know. Probably it’s the same deal as being an escort, like, ‘with or without blow jobs.’”
Okay, that made sense, but—“Who’s going to pay to date me ?” Jem had a hard enough time getting dates who didn’t pay for the privilege. He was kind of a bitch.
“Uh, lots of people?” Tori furrowed her brow. “You’re hot. We live in California. Rich people everywhere. The world is your oyster.”
“I’m allergic to shellfish.”
“Oh my God, Jem.” She slapped his thigh, then dug in his pocket for his phone, because she’d never had a strong grasp of personal space. “Look, there’s probably even, like, a dating app for that. It’ll be easy. You just make a profile, set up a couple dates, find a rich loser who’s looking for some arm candy, and give them the boyfriend experience.”
The boyfriend…? “Is that a sex thing?”
“What?” She huffed. “Look, as much as it pains me to say it, I have seen you date. When you’re in it, you’re in it, you know? You’re a good boyfriend. You’re thoughtful, you’re a good cook, you clean up after yourself. You probably pack them lunches with cute little love notes in them.”
That wasn’t totally true. Jem had never written a love note. But he’d written dumb jokes on Post-it Notes for his college girlfriend and put them on the coffee maker for when she had early labs. He liked waking up to the sound of her laughter, even if he didn’t always get out of bed when he heard it.
It broke his heart when she moved to Germany to do her postdoc, but he understood. She had to follow her passion, her research, and Jem had young minds to shape.
“You think someone’s going to pay me for that.”
“Pff.” She unlocked his phone and went right to the app store. In less than thirty seconds, she slapped it back into his hands. “I know someone will. Look. We’re gonna have to do some research, obviously, but you could do this.”
Jem looked down at the screen. FindMyBaby. Good Christ. “Let’s try extreme couponing first,” he suggested.
“I think you’d have better luck as an investment banker,” Tori told him, but she didn’t push the issue. “Come on. I’ll buy you groceries and you can make me dinner.”
“Deal.”
Jem kept thinking about it. He thought about it at the grocery store the next week, when coupons brought his bill down to $57.14 from $63.77. He thought about it on Wednesday morning on his way to work as he put air in his rear passenger-side tire and noticed how worn it had gotten. He thought about it when he was waiting with his students for their parents to pick them up. But only a third of them got picked up by their parents; the rest had nannies to do the job. Even the nannies had nicer shoes than Jem, which was galling because Jem was an expert in thrifting designer kicks. Most of their cars cost twice what Jem made in a year.
Of course, the nannies probably didn’t have to pay rent and they didn’t own the cars they drove. But still.
Friday was payday. Jem checked his bank balance at lunch, leaned his head back against the wall, and resolved to find Tori before she left for the day.
He managed it only because she found him first; Tori didn’t have to supervise pickup. She breezed into his classroom just after his last student was escorted out by his mother, who dressed like a Secret Service agent if Secret Service agents wore Versace and Louboutins.
“So,” Tori said.
Jem closed his eyes. “Can I come over and make you and Ivy dinner?” Neither of them could cook for shit, which was especially inconvenient for them now that Ivy was expecting. “And maybe you can, uh… help me with my profile?”
She smiled widely. “Jem Anderson, it would be my honor.”
Ivy worked from home a lot—one of the benefits of the post-Covid life and one she took more advantage of now that she was experiencing the joys of morning sickness.
Eight months ago Jem had come over to make dinner, and afterward Tori pulled him downstairs and ambushed him with “Ivy wants to have a baby.”
Jem had blinked. “Uh.” Tori hadn’t said anything about what she wanted. “That’s usually a ‘two yes, one no’ situation.”
Tori nodded like a broken bobblehead. “In this case we’re looking for three yeses because neither of us can be the sperm donor.”
“So like… you, Tori Foster, want to have a baby.”
Finally she looked up at him again, cheeks flushed with indignation. “I like kids! I'm a teacher!”
“Yes,” Jem agreed, “and you routinely gripe about how disgusting children are, so… I just want to make sure, you know? That it’s what you want too.” Years-ago Tori—first-friend-Jem-made-in-college Tori—had not.
But people changed.
“I didn’t think I wanted it,” she admitted. “Like, in college, not being able to get pregnant by accident was a huge perk of being a lesbian. But I don’t know…. Then I met Ivy, and she’s so—I mean the woman can do anything. Including make me want kids, apparently.” The flush was sweeter now. Affection, embarrassment… love. True love.
“Wow.” Jem cleared his throat, feeling like he’d fallen short of the enthusiasm a best friend should show for this kind of thing. “Then congratulations, obviously. You’re going to be great at it.”
Tori smiled, uncharacteristically shy. “Thanks. Ivy wants—we both want—a family that’s like, ours, you know, so, I mean. Originally she was like, what if Mike is our sperm donor—”
Jem tried to control it. He wanted so badly to be supportive. But he could feel his eyes bulging in horror.
“—but I said I’d suck my uterus out with a toilet plunger before I let Mike’s jizz anywhere near me, and she said yeah, that’s fair.”
“Thank God.”
“Right?” She shook her head. “I don’t know what she was thinking. And then she said, well—actually that’s when she said she wants to be the one to carry the baby? So she said maybe it’s better if my brother does the, you know.” She mimed jerking off.
Jem was still nodding until he realized, “Uh, Victoria, you don't have a brother.”
Tori just looked at him, patient and earnest. “Jem.”
Oh shit . “You want me to—” He realized how loud he was getting and adjusted. “You want me to knock up your wife?!”
“Not, like, in person or anything. Gross!”
So anyway, shortly afterward Jem and Tori and Ivy had gone from being family to being family family, and Jem was still kind of awestruck that he got to be part of it. He dropped a kiss on Ivy’s cheek when he came in, then took in the legal pad, three highlighters, two pens, and the phone she had in front of her and shot a betrayed look at Tori. “You already talked to her?”
“Jem, I love you but I am the world’s most committed lesbian. If you want to hook some male-attracted whale to pay your bills, we’re gonna need an assist from a certified man-appreciator.”
He turned to Ivy. “You’ve been with Tori for like five years; your certification still valid?”
“Oh, yeah,” Ivy deadpanned. “I renew every year when I do my license plate. But I do my best work when someone’s making me dinner.”
“Guess I better get started, then.” Jem rolled up his sleeves, washed his hands, and got to work.
At the kitchen table, Tori opened the app on his phone and read through the profile questions while Ivy made notes by hand.
“Okay, first question, Mr. James Anderson.” She must’ve had to fill out his legal name. “Do you have a preferred gender for your sugar parent.”
“Not really.” He splashed a bit of olive oil in the bottom of a Dutch oven. “You know I’m bi.”
“What if you get matched with someone who’s nonbinary?”
“Can you put pan?” He glanced over his shoulder. “Like, I’m not interested in what’s in anyone’s pants, I only care about what’s in their wallets.”
“We are not putting that in your profile,” Ivy said primly.
“We should,” Tori dissented. “Jem should get a sugar daddy who appreciates his humor.”
Jem had no opinion on that, so he shrugged and pushed a handful of ground beef into the pot.
Ivy cleared her throat. “Moving on.”
There was a beat, and then Tori read the next question. “What kind of arrangement are you looking for? This one is like, three-part multiple choice. The first part is how often you’re willing to meet with someone, from once a month to multiple times a week, and the second part is whether you’re looking for short- or long-term partnerships, and the last one is whether you’re open to multiple simultaneous partnerships. Then there’s, like, a spot for you to write specifics.” She paused. “Let’s go with no on the multiples. Like, this is baby’s first paid situationship.”
“Yeah, duh. Thanks, Tori.” He stirred the meat to break it up. “Let’s go with two or three times a week tops, weekends preferred, one weekday per week max, and long-term.” It wasn’t like he had a lot of homework to mark, but he still had to do evaluations and lesson plans and write report card comments, and sometimes the kids just took it out of him.
The next section apparently concerned Jem’s areas of expertise, which Tori could fill out as well as he could by this point.
“You speak Spanish?” Ivy asked, peering over Tori’s shoulder as she scrolled through the questions.
“I’m not fluent, but yeah. Maria who runs the day care with my mom is Mexican.” Jem had basically grown up in that day care, and plenty of the other employees at the golf course had been immigrants too, so he’d picked up a fair amount.
“Got it. Oh, hey, scroll back up. You forgot to click that he plays guitar.”
Jem brought his guitar in to do sing-alongs with his students, which he personally thought didn’t count, but Ivy was the expert.
When the meat had browned and Jem had removed it to deglaze with the onions, Ivy said, “Okay, now we’re getting to the good stuff. Tell us about your date comfort zones.”
Jesus Christ. “What does that even mean?”
“Like, if someone takes you to a salsa bar…,” Tori prompted.
“The kind where they serve tortilla chips or the kind with ladies in red dresses?”
He glanced over in time to see Ivy cover a snort with her hand. “Let’s assume the focus is on the second one.”
Jem and Tori brainstormed a list—“I know way too much about your areas of competence, Anderson. Sporting events, golf, knowing which fork to use at fancy dinners, clubbing. Oh, hey, do you think anyone’s looking for a guy who can do a keg stand? Child-minding, black tie, talking to rich people like you’re one of them—”
“Why is this starting to sound like an indictment of my character?” Jem wondered as he scraped the rest of the vegetables into the pot.
“I can’t imagine,” Tori said airily.
The questionnaire wound down just as the chili finished cooking, with Tori proclaiming, “Okay, there’s a section on, like, whether and what kind of time you’re willing to spend with your dates without your clothes on, but that’s none of my business and I’d rather not know, so… I think we’re done.”
Fuck, in an hour or so, Jem was going to have to decide if he was willing to put naked time on the table. For now he settled for putting dinner on the table. “Great.” He flashed a small smile. “Thank you for the help, really. It’s, uh… it means a lot.”
Ivy reached across the table and squeezed his hand. “Of course. It was fun. And thank you for saving us from takeout for another night.”
“Hey, you know I’m in love with your kitchen.”
Tori paused with her spoon halfway to her mouth. “Do you think we need to add that to your profile? ‘Weirdly turned on by functional design’?”
Ivy elbowed her, looked over teasingly, then glanced back at Jem. “Is that a feature or a bug?”
Jem’s friends were such dorks. He was so lucky. “You’re the expert.”
“Feature, definitely, if it gets me fed like this.”
Jem flushed at the compliment. Sue him; he liked knowing he made people happy.
Conversation died off as they all concentrated on their dinner, but when Jem was about halfway through his bowl, he caught Tori and Ivy giving each other a married-couple wordless look.
Jem made a bet with himself about who’d speak first. His money was on Tori. She usually did the heavy lifting when she thought Jem needed handling.
Good thing he didn’t make the bet with anyone else, because he was broke and it was Ivy who broached the subject. “Jem, you know we support you if you want to do this sugar-baby thing. We’d never judge you for that.” She put her spoon down and blinked at him with those wide, earnest brown eyes. “But if you don’t want to do it—if you’re doing it because you think you have to—we could give you a loan.”
Jem was already shaking his head. “No, that’s—I can’t accept that. I don’t know when I’d be able to pay you back, and then it wouldn’t be a loan.”
To his relief, Ivy didn’t push it, just smiled her acceptance. “Okay. Well, offer stands.”
“Told you,” Tori muttered, sticking out her tongue.
Ivy laughed at her. “Oh my God.”
It was just a normal dinner after that. Ivy insisted on doing the dishes while Jem finished the last of his profile. He had to admit, the biography she’d written him sounded—well, it sounded embarrassing, but embarrassing in a way that suited Jem and would likely attract the kind of people he wouldn’t mind spending time with.
Jem A., twenty-seven-year-old former NCAA athlete, now a young professional himbo with golden retriever energy. Whether you need me to crush it on the golf course, charm investors at a charity gala, or pour margaritas by the pool, I can do it all and look good doing it. Rather hang out at home? That’s cool, I’ll make you dinner and we’ll trash-talk X Factor. The world is your oyster when you’re with me (unless you like actual oysters, because I’m allergic to shellfish).
“I thought you said I wasn’t a himbo, just himbo-presenting,” he said to Tori, playing up his puppy-dog eyes.
“We could edit to ‘himbo-presenting golden retriever,’” Ivy said, “but that seems redundant, and there’s a character limit.”
“Nah, it’s great, actually. Thank you again.” He smiled and hit Submit, then closed the app. “For the first time, I actually feel pretty good about this.”
“That’s my wife.” Tori smacked a kiss on her cheek.
He zoned out on the drive home and only noticed the Prius’s exceptionally sluggish handling when he put it in Park in the apartment lot and it made a gasping, wheezy noise when he turned it off. When he tried to start it again, nothing happened.
Jem leaned forward and banged his head gently against the steering wheel. As far as signs from the universe went, this one was pretty obvious.
Chapter Two
Be My Sugar Baby
Jem figured it would take some time for the whole sugar-baby ball to start rolling. Background checks, police clearances, identity verification—this wasn’t just some online hookup service. And surely whoever was on the other end would want to, like, think things through or whatever. He probably should’ve known better; rich people treated sugar babies the way they treated everything else—the newest thing was the best thing.
Jem got his first response half an hour after he received notification that his profile had been cleared and activated. They wanted to meet the next day at noon. As he stared into his closet that night, he called Ivy and said, “Hey, what do I wear to meet a potential sugar mama?” because Tori’s idea of fashion was a clean T-shirt and pants with enough pockets to double as a tool box.
After a five-minute FaceTime call, Ivy picked an outfit that embodied pool boy —deck shoes, white pants, bright polo, sunglasses—and pronounced him fit for consumption.
Which was about right, Jem thought, because the woman who sat across from him in the private back room of the high-end café she’d selected for this meeting looked like she wanted to eat him.
“You must be Jem,” she said smoothly as she rose from her chair. She was Caucasian, slender, with a bright purple manicure and highlighted red-brown hair. She could’ve been forty or sixty, though Jem guessed it was closer to the upper end. “I’m Caroline.”
Jem debated half a second before shaking her hand instead of kissing it. She had a firm grip and the kind of smooth skin that spoke of expensive moisturizer. “Nice to meet you, Caroline.”
“Oh, the pleasure is all mine,” she said lightly. Then, lips pursed, lashes fluttering, “Well, maybe not all of it.”
Laughing, Jem sank into the chair across from her. “That’s one way to break the ice, I guess.”
“I have some experience with first-timers.” She paused and actually seemed embarrassed by the implication. “Oh dear. I mean first-time… companions. Not virgins. Christ. You’re not a virgin, are you, Jem?”
“Not the last time I checked,” he answered faintly. This lady was dangerous.
Caroline laughed. “Okay, good. Now that’s out of the way, do you drink coffee? Tea? I personally love a flat white, or Jeremy makes a mean London fog.”
“How does Jeremy feel about iced coffee?”
“If he’s a snob about it, he’d better keep that information to himself,” Caroline advised. She took out her phone and sent a text message—their drinks order, presumably—and then placed it back on the table, facedown. “So, Jem. Can I tell you a little about myself, or is that too forward?”
“At this point I think it might actually count as going in reverse.” Jem could tell he was flushing, a little, but she was an attractive woman and her candor put him at ease. If he was going to be interviewing for the position of sugar baby, he’d have to get used to conversations like these. At least Caroline made it fun.
She chuckled, then leaned back in her chair as a barista—Jeremy, presumably—came in to deliver their drink order.
When Jeremy left again, Caroline folded her hands around her coffee cup. “As I was saying, I’m Caroline. I’ve been widowed once and divorced twice and I’m just over the whole”—she waved a hand—“soul mate thing . But that doesn’t mean I like being alone.”
“I get it. I get tired of my own company too.”
“So you understand.” She smiled in delight. “It’s boring, rattling around in my big old mansion alone all the time, so I throw a lot of parties.”
Jem thought, Sex parties? and it must have shown on his face, because she shook her head. “Industry parties, Jem. Introducing people to each other. Networking. No fancy underpants required.”
To give himself a moment, Jem picked up his iced coffee and took a sip. Jeremy was a fucking wizard. He made a pleased noise, set the cup down again, and asked, “Fancy underpants optional?”
Caroline chuckled again. “Oh, that depends on the guests. But mostly they’re R-rated at most. For language, smoking, drinking. Occasionally other substances. So the first thing I’m looking for is a young, handsome, charming cohost. I have to say, you’re nailing that part of the interview.”
“Aw, shucks.” But he tapped his fingers on the table, because he did have to draw a line. “I’m assuming participation in the other substances is optional? The day job is not beyond occasional random drug testing.”
“Of course,” Caroline agreed. “I should have realized—you did say young professional , didn’t you? Can I ask what you do for work?”
He cleared his throat. “Ah, I teach kindergarten. Private school.”
“Shaping young minds,” she said approvingly. “How darling. Well, you don’t have to worry. You can abstain from anything that might get you in trouble.” Her smile turned mischievous. “In trouble at work, at least.”
Oh boy. Jem had a feeling he knew where the conversation would go next. “I appreciate that.”
Sure enough, Caroline took another sip of her coffee and then leaned forward. “Now, Jem. Let’s talk about you a little bit. Your profile says you’re open to negotiating more intimate arrangements. I’m sure it won’t come as a surprise that that’s my primary interest.”
“I may have guessed.”
“I can be a very demanding woman.” She smiled as she admitted this, maybe because she followed it up with, “And a generous one.”
Jem picked up the piece of paper she slid across the table and glanced at it. A number with a significant number of zeroes was written on the other side.
“This is what I’m offering on a monthly basis, as well as gifts—you’ll need appropriate clothing for the parties, jewelry, so on. I’d expect you to stay over on weekends, of course.”
“Uh-huh,” Jem said faintly, trying to process the number. Was this the beginning of his inexorable transition into prostitution and debauchery? Because from where he was sitting, it was a pretty sweet deal.
But….
With a deep breath, he raised his eyes to meet Caroline’s. Her gaze was shrewd, assessing, but not unkind.
“You’re turning me down,” she said mildly.
“Honestly, I think I’m more surprised than you are.” He gave her a weak smile and pushed the paper back toward her, as though she’d need it for something else. “It’s not—definitely nothing you did or said. You’re funny, you’re attractive, I think we’d have a good time.”
“But?” Caroline prompted.
He blew out a long breath and tried to put words to it. “Cold feet?” he said. “That’s not it exactly, just, uh. I’m gonna be real with you, the idea of getting paid that much for my dick is gonna give me performance anxiety.”
She broke into a peal of surprised laughter. “Now, I’m not sure I believe that.”
It was as close as Jem could come to explaining. He shook his head slightly. “I think it all just got too real. I need some time for it to sink in, you know? And this is my very first, um, interview? I feel like there’s a difference between jumping in the deep end knowing you can swim and doing a polar dip.”
“Hmm.” Caroline considered him. “I suppose I might be something of a shock to the system.”
Lady, that’s putting it mildly .
“I’ll tell you what.” She reached into her purse and withdrew a business card, which she passed across the table. “You go see what’s out there, and if you don’t find something that suits you, give me a call.”
Jem took the card and smiled. “Sounds like a plan. I will. Thanks, Caroline.”
Of course, the interview itself was fine. The debrief with Tori afterward, however—
“Tell me everything,” she demanded. “No, wait, if there were bodily fluids exchanged, I don’t want to hear that part.”
Jem was literally the one who taught her how to go down on a girl, once upon a time, but whatever. He rolled his eyes. “It wasn’t an audition . It was just coffee with a potential… client.”
“Uh-huh. And do you always discuss your dick size on your coffee dates?”
“Caroline did not ask how big my dick was.”
Apparently Tori had not anticipated this. “Wait, really?”
And—well. Jem made it a habit not to lie to her. “I wore the white chinos.” He’d bought them online, intending to make them part of his work wardrobe, but he’d only worn them to school once before Tori informed him why he would not be doing that again.
“Oh, so she’s seen it.”
The pants weren’t translucent , just… tailored. Jem sighed. “Tori.”
“Right, right, okay, I’m focusing. Tell me about her.”
“She was hot. Older, I don’t know how much, but like, at least forty, probably fifty. Definitely works out, hair and nails done on schedule. Beverly Hills type for sure.”
“I should’ve known you’d be cougar bait. Did you like her? Or was it, like, skeevy?”
“I mean, the first thing she said to me was a sex joke,” Jem admitted. “But she was funny about it. It wasn’t pushy or anything. I did like her.”
“Amazing. So you’re going through with it?”
“Uh. No.”
“Why not?”
“Tori, that lady would’ve rode me hard and put me away dead.”
“You mean wet?”
“I meant what I said. I was gonna be calling in at the start of every week ’cause I would’ve been too sore to get out of bed.”
Tori cackled. “Jem, she was like fifty years old. You don’t think you could keep up?”
“Without performance-enhancing drugs? She was gonna have my dick twice for breakfast and follow up with my shin bone for brunch if she couldn’t get a third helping.” Jem was more than happy to be of service, but he wasn’t sure his ego could handle that.
“Jem! Gross!” The cackles turned into breathless wheezes. “College Jem would’ve gone for it.”
He snorted. “College Jem would’ve done it for free and called it part of his education. But College Jem didn’t have to wrangle twenty five-year-olds come Monday morning.”
The smile in her voice was obvious when she said, “You’re still tempted, huh?”
Want to keep reading?
Buy this book Excerpt © Ashlyn Kane. Published by Dreamspinner Press.